Of course! Here is a very lengthy and detailed guide on how to value Berkshire Hathaway stock.
How to Value Berkshire Hathaway Stock: A Comprehensive Guide for the Astute Investor
Hello, future value investor! Are you ready to embark on one of the most intriguing and challenging valuation journeys in the stock market? Valuing Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A, BRK.B) isn't like valuing a typical company. It's a complex, multi-faceted conglomerate—a "collection of businesses" as Warren Buffett himself calls it—and requires a unique approach. Forget your standard P/E ratio analysis and let's dive deep into the world of the Oracle of Omaha's creation.
Ready? Let's get started.
 |
| How To Value Berkshire Hathaway Stock |
Step 1: Understand What You're Valuing
Before you even touch a calculator, you must grasp the very essence of Berkshire Hathaway. This is not just a stock; it's a holding company with a massive, diversified portfolio.
The Two Engines: Think of Berkshire as having two main engines:
Wholly-Owned Businesses: This is the heart of Berkshire. These are companies like GEICO, BNSF Railway, Precision Castparts, and many others, which are not publicly traded. You won't find their individual stock prices, but their earnings and cash flows are what drive a significant portion of Berkshire's value.
The Investment Portfolio: This is the part that gets most of the headlines. It's the massive portfolio of publicly traded stocks, with large positions in companies like Apple, Bank of America, Coca-Cola, and American Express. The value of this portfolio fluctuates with the market.
BRK.A vs. BRK.B: A key distinction is between the two share classes. BRK.A (Class A) is the original, extremely expensive share that has never split. BRK.B (Class B) was created to be more accessible to retail investors. While they represent different ownership stakes and have different voting rights, for valuation purposes, the value of one BRK.A share is equivalent to 1,500 BRK.B shares. The core business value is the same, just divided into different pieces.
Cash is King: Berkshire Hathaway consistently holds a colossal amount of cash and short-term investments, often over $100 billion. This "dry powder" is a crucial component of its value and provides a significant margin of safety and flexibility for future acquisitions.
So, are you ready to look beyond the stock ticker and see the collection of powerful businesses underneath? Let's move on to the actual valuation process!
QuickTip: Focus more on the ‘how’ than the ‘what’.
Step 2: The Sum-of-the-Parts Valuation Method
This is the most logical and widely accepted method for valuing Berkshire Hathaway. You're essentially breaking down the company into its individual components, valuing each part, and then summing them up to arrive at a total intrinsic value.
Sub-heading 2.1: Valuing the Wholly-Owned Businesses
This is the trickiest part, as you don't have a public market price to guide you. The goal is to estimate their "earnings power."
Identify Key Segments: Look at Berkshire's annual report (the 10-K filing) and quarterly reports (10-Q). You'll see segments like Insurance, Railroads (BNSF), Utilities & Energy (BHE), and Manufacturing, Service, and Retailing.
Estimate Earnings Power: For each segment, analyze the operating earnings. Don't just look at one year; examine the historical trend. What is the normal, sustainable earnings power of these businesses? You want to see their normalized earnings, not just a one-off gain or loss.
Apply a Multiple: This is where your judgment comes in. You need to assign a multiple (like a Price-to-Earnings or P/E ratio) to these earnings to get a valuation for each segment.
BNSF Railway: As a regulated utility-like business, it might deserve a stable P/E multiple.
GEICO: The insurance business is complex, but you can look at its underwriting profit and float.
Manufacturing, Service, and Retailing: This is a diverse group. You might need to look at industry averages for similar companies to get a sense of an appropriate multiple.
Sum it Up: Add up the valuations of all the wholly-owned segments to get their combined value.
Sub-heading 2.2: Valuing the Investment Portfolio
Tip: Reread tricky sentences for clarity.
This part is much more straightforward.
Identify the Holdings: Berkshire's 13F filings with the SEC disclose their equity holdings. You'll find a list of all their publicly traded stocks, such as Apple, Bank of America, etc.
Use Market Value: Simply take the number of shares Berkshire owns in each company and multiply it by the current market price.
Calculate the Total: Add up the market value of all the stocks in the portfolio. This number fluctuates daily, so your valuation will be a snapshot in time.
Sub-heading 2.3: Accounting for Cash and Debt
This is a simple but critical step.
Add Cash and Equivalents: Take the total cash and short-term investments from Berkshire's balance sheet and add it to your valuation. This is a liquid asset that is readily available.
Subtract Debt: Find the total debt on the balance sheet and subtract it. Berkshire's debt is often a mix of corporate debt and debt from its subsidiaries, like BNSF Railway, so make sure you're using the total.
Step 3: Calculating the Intrinsic Value Per Share
Once you've valued all the pieces, you can put it all together to get a per-share value.
Sum the Parts:
(Value of Wholly-Owned Businesses) + (Value of Investment Portfolio) + (Cash & Equivalents) - (Total Debt) = Total Intrinsic Value
Divide by Shares Outstanding: Now, take that total intrinsic value and divide it by the total number of Class A and Class B shares outstanding. Remember to convert all Class A shares to their Class B equivalent (Class A shares x 1,500) or vice versa to get the total share count.
Total Intrinsic Value / (Class B Shares Outstanding + (Class A Shares Outstanding x 1,500)) = Intrinsic Value Per BRK.B Share
Tip: Pause, then continue with fresh focus.
Step 4: Apply a Margin of Safety
Warren Buffett's mentor, Benjamin Graham, taught him the importance of a "margin of safety." This is the difference between your calculated intrinsic value and the current market price.
Compare to Market Price: Look at the current stock price of BRK.B.
Determine Your Buy Price: If your calculated intrinsic value is significantly higher than the current market price, you have a margin of safety. A 20-30% discount is often a good starting point for a margin of safety, but it's a personal decision.
Consider Qualitative Factors: A number is a number, but Berkshire is more than that. Consider the qualitative factors as well:
The quality of the management team: Is the management team capable of continuing Buffett's legacy? (Greg Abel has been named the successor to the CEO role, a key consideration for the future).
The strength of the brands: Many of Berkshire's subsidiaries are market leaders with strong brands.
The corporate culture: The decentralized, long-term focused culture is a significant asset.
Step 5: Alternative Valuation Method - Earnings Power
While the sum-of-the-parts is the most detailed approach, another method is to focus on the company's "earnings power." This is what Warren Buffett himself often focuses on.
Calculate "Owner Earnings": This is a metric Buffett uses. It’s a bit more complex than simple net income. It’s roughly calculated as: Net Income + Depreciation & Amortization - Capital Expenditures needed to maintain operations. This gives you a truer picture of the cash flow a business can generate for its owners.
Assign a P/E Multiple to Owner Earnings: Again, this requires judgment. Given Berkshire's stability and diversified nature, you could apply a multiple that reflects its low-risk profile.
Add the Investment Portfolio and Cash: Don't forget to add the market value of the investment portfolio and the cash on the balance sheet to this earnings power value.
This method can be a quick sanity check against your sum-of-the-parts valuation.
10 Related FAQ Subheadings
Tip: A slow skim is better than a rushed read.
How to find the latest Berkshire Hathaway financial reports? You can find Berkshire Hathaway's latest 10-K (annual) and 10-Q (quarterly) filings on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) EDGAR database. These are the official documents you need.
How to account for the insurance "float" in the valuation? The insurance float is the money collected in premiums that an insurer holds before it pays out claims. It's essentially a no-cost source of capital for Berkshire. While not directly added as a cash value, its value is in the income it generates from investments and the fact that it's a permanent and growing source of capital. Its value is embedded in the earnings power of the insurance businesses.
How to value Berkshire's private investments and subsidiaries that are not publicly traded? You need to estimate their earnings power and apply a reasonable multiple based on comparable publicly traded companies in that industry. For example, for BNSF, you can look at the valuation multiples of other large railroads.
How to treat Berkshire's massive cash pile in the valuation? The cash pile is a direct asset and should be added at its face value to the intrinsic value calculation. It's a liquid asset that can be used for acquisitions, buybacks, or investments.
How to understand the difference in price between BRK.A and BRK.B? The price difference is purely a function of the share structure. One BRK.A share is convertible into 1,500 BRK.B shares. The price of BRK.B is simply the price of BRK.A divided by 1,500, with minor market fluctuations.
How to determine an appropriate discount rate for a DCF valuation of Berkshire? Given Berkshire's stability and diversification, a lower discount rate (e.g., 7-9%) is often appropriate. This reflects the lower risk compared to a single, less-diversified business.
How to adjust for the tax liability on the unrealized gains of the investment portfolio? This is a more advanced consideration. Some analysts will apply a theoretical tax rate to the unrealized gains on the investment portfolio and subtract that amount from the total value. This is a conservative approach, as the tax is only paid when the shares are sold.
How to factor in the potential for future acquisitions in the valuation? You can't precisely value future acquisitions, but you can acknowledge the management's capital allocation prowess. The large cash pile gives Berkshire the option to make a massive, value-creating acquisition, which is a qualitative benefit not captured in the numbers.
How to analyze Berkshire's management and its impact on the valuation? Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger's exceptional capital allocation skills are a key reason for Berkshire's success. While they are aging, Greg Abel's succession is a critical factor. You should consider whether the future management team can continue this legacy of prudent capital allocation.
How to check if Berkshire Hathaway is currently undervalued? After performing your sum-of-the-parts or earnings power valuation, compare your calculated intrinsic value per share to the current market price of BRK.B. If the market price is at a significant discount to your calculated value, it might be a sign of undervaluation. You can also look at metrics like Price-to-Book value, although for Berkshire, this metric has become less reliable over time.
 |
