Theo Graves: From Disco Darling to Dirt Nap? How AHS: NYC Left Us Hanging (Literally)
Ah, Theo. The wide-eyed photographer with a heart of gold (and a penchant for questionable knitwear). He waltzed into our living rooms in AHS: NYC with a smile that could melt glaciers, but sadly, his time in the Big Apple was cut a little short. The question that's been burning brighter than a disco ball on roller skates is: how did our guy Theo kick the bucket?
Theories Wilder Than Donna Summer's Outfits:
Let's be honest, AHS loves to play coy with its endings. Theo's fate is no different. Here are the top contenders for what took Theo down:
-
The Evil Ex: Remember Sam, the model with the morals of a back alley deal? Yeah, she wasn't exactly thrilled Theo bounced from her orbit. Some fans think Sam drugged Theo and left him for dead at the infamous Fire Island meat rack. Spicy! But is it far-fetched?
-
The Big D: AHS: NYC never explicitly mentions AIDS, but the show throws some serious shade in that direction. Theo, along with a few other characters, exhibit symptoms that line up with the disease. This would be a darker turn, but it reflects the harsh realities of the time period.
-
Big Daddy's Big Mistake: Big Daddy, the leather-clad guardian of the meat rack, does show up to scare off a potential attacker. Did his intervention come too late? Did Theo succumb to the elements (and questionable fashion choices) while tied to a tree? The drama!
The Truth (Maybe):
The truth is, we just don't know for sure. The show leaves Theo's fate ambiguous, which is equal parts frustrating and intriguing. Did he succumb to illness? Was Sam a scorned-lover-turned-serial-killer? Did Big Daddy accidentally strangle him with his enthusiasm? The world may never know.
But hey, that's the beauty (and sometimes the frustration) of AHS! It leaves us room to speculate, to write angsty fan fiction, and to argue with our friends on internet forums until the cows come home (or, you know, the next season premieres).
So, what do you think, AHS fans? Did Theo get a glitter-filled send-off or a dirt nap under the disco ball moon? Let's hear your wildest theories in the comments below!
💡 This page may contain affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
