The Forbidden Art: Pitching with a Position Player in MLB the Show (Because Real Baseball Managers Never Do... Much)
Let's face it, folks. We've all been there. You're cruising through a game in MLB the Show, feeling like Randy Johnson in his prime. Then, WHAM! Your trusty starter forgets how to throw strikes and turns into a walking wild pitch machine. Panic sets in faster than you can say "blown lead."
Here's where things get interesting. You glance at your bullpen, and it resembles a post-apocalyptic wasteland – everyone's burnt toast. But wait! There, nestled amongst your position players, sits your secret weapon. Maybe it's the speedy outfielder with a hidden knuckleball. Perhaps it's the first baseman with a mean sidearm delivery honed in Little League. Whatever the case, the crazy idea of pitching with a position player starts flickering in your mind.
Now, before you unleash your inner maverick manager, there are a few things to consider. This ain't exactly Moneyball, and the risk/reward is about as lopsided as a clown car. But hey, where's the fun in playing it safe?
Why You Might Be Crazy Enough to Try This
Let's be honest, pitching with a position player is the ultimate "because I can" move. It's a power play for the ages, a surefire way to make your opponent do a spit-take into their Mountain Dew. Plus, if you pull it off? Instant legend status. Imagine the bragging rights! You'll be the hero of online forums, the envy of your friends, the "#PitchingWith [Insert Player Name]" meme factory.
But Before You Go Full "Starsky & Hutch" with Your Lineup...
There's a reason real-life managers rarely unleash their Yadier Molinas to the mound. Here's a reality check:
- Accuracy: Let's just say "throwing strikes consistently" might not be on your outfielder's resume. Be prepared for a lot of wild pitches and walks.
- Velocity: Unless you have a superhuman outfielder with a rocket arm, forget about overpowering anyone.
- Stamina: Position players aren't built for the wear and tear of pitching. They might tire quickly, leading to even more control issues.
So You Still Want to Do This? Here's How (Maybe) Not to Get Embarrassed
- Choose Your Weapon Wisely: Not all position players are created equal. Look for someone with decent control ratings (think a good Fielding stat) and maybe a funky throwing motion (think a sidearm specialist).
- The Pinch-Hit Shuffle: You can't just swap your pitcher for a position player on the mound mid-inning. MLB the Show has pesky rules (unlike your basement simulation league). Here's the trick: If you're playing in the National League (where pitchers bat), pinch hit for your pitcher with your chosen position player. This will automatically put them on the mound next inning.
- Manage Expectations: Go in with the mindset of "controlled chaos." Aim for weak contact, not strikeouts. Changeups and off-speed pitches might be your best friends here.
- Embrace the Chaos: This is pure, unadulterated baseball madness. Laugh at the wild pitches, celebrate the weak groundouts. Remember, you're playing for the memes at this point.
The Final Verdict: Pitching with a Position Player - A High-Risk, High-Reward Proposition
Look, pitching with a position player is a gamble. It might backfire spectacularly. But hey, that's half the fun, right? So, the next time you're staring down defeat, remember this guide. With a little bit of luck and a whole lot of audacity, you might just become a legend (or a cautionary tale). Just don't blame me if your opponent quits in sheer amusement.
