The Great NYC Jewish Deli Showdown: A Quest for Pastrami Paradise (and Maybe a Pickle on the Side)
Ah, the New York City Jewish deli. A place of piled-high sandwiches, grumpy waiters with a heart of gold (or at least a heart that tolerates your indecisiveness), and enough pickles to make a bubbe proud. But with so many contenders, where do you, a pastrami-craving pilgrim, even begin? Fear not, my friend, for I have embarked on this epicurean adventure for you!
The Contenders: A Rogues' Gallery of Rye Bread Royalty
- Katz's Deli: This Lower East Side legend boasts a pastrami legacy longer than your Bubbe's brisket recipe. Be warned: ordering can be a delightfully chaotic experience, but hey, that's part of the charm (and maybe why they don't take credit cards...keeps things old school, you know?)
- 2nd Ave Deli: Katz's may have the legacy, but 2nd Ave Deli has the reputation for the absolute meatyist pastrami in the city. Be prepared for a sandwich so colossal it could feed a small village (or at least your entire Netflix queue).
- Sarge's Delicatessen: This modern-ish take on the classic deli scene offers pastrami that's both melt-in-your-mouth tender and bursting with flavor. Plus, their matzo ball soup is a guaranteed cure for whatever ails you (except maybe overindulging in pastrami).
The Verdict: It's a Schmear-ocracy!
Truth is, there's no single "best" deli in NYC. It's a matter of personal taste, atmosphere, and how much of a pastrami mountain you can conquer. Here's a (slightly subjective) breakdown:
- For the Classic Experience: Go with Katz's. Embrace the chaos, soak in the history, and prepare to be wowed (and possibly intimidated) by the sheer size of their sandwiches.
- For the Meats-a-Palooza: 2nd Ave Deli is your champion. Just make sure you bring your appetite (and maybe a friend to share with).
- For the Modern Twist: Hit up Sarge's. You'll get incredible pastrami alongside a more relaxed vibe.
Bonus Round: The Dark Horse
- Mile End Delicatessen: This Montreal-inspired spot offers a delicious twist on the classic deli experience with their famous smoked meat.
The Final Word: It's All Good
No matter where you choose, you're in for a treat. Just remember to loosen your belt a notch (or two), grab a napkin (because trust me, you'll need it), and get ready to experience a true New York City tradition. And hey, if you can't decide, who says you can't embark on your own pastrami pilgrimage and hit them all? Just don't blame me when your pants protest.
💡 This page may contain affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
