The Great Wage Whoops-a-Daisy: Can Your Boss Claw Back Cash in New York?
Let's face it, nobody's perfect. Not even payroll departments. Sometimes, due to a rogue decimal point or a gremlin in the system, you might end up with a paycheck that looks more like a lottery ticket. But before you start planning your victory lap around the office water cooler, hold on to your horses (or that new yacht you were dreaming of buying). In New York, employers can actually try to get that money back under certain circumstances. Bummer, right?
So, When Can Your Boss Become Scrooge McDuck?
There are a few key things to consider:
The Blame Game: The Clerical Caper - If the overpayment was due to a simple mistake by your employer, like a typo or a miscalculation, then yes, they can try to recoup the funds. But there are rules!
The Clock's Ticking: The 8-Week Window - Your employer can only go after overpayments made within the past eight weeks. So, if it's been longer than that rainy afternoon you received the surprise paycheck, breathe a sigh of relief (and maybe buy yourself a celebratory donut).
The Great Paycheck Payback Caper: Deducto-Dash - If your employer wants their money back, they generally have to take it out of your future paychecks in small chunks. They can't just take the whole whack in one go! There are limits! They can only deduct a maximum of 12.5% of your gross wages per pay period, and those deductions can't bring your hourly rate below the minimum wage.
Important Side Note: If you think the deduction is unfair or the mistake wasn't yours, you have rights! New York State Department of Labor is there to help.
But Wait, There's More! (The Not-So-Funny Part)
The Intentional Error: Uh Oh Spaghetti-O's - If you knowingly received more than you were owed and didn't say anything, your employer has a stronger case to get it back. Honesty is always the best policy, folks!
The Statute of Limitations: The Six-Year Saga - This might seem like a lifetime, but your employer has six years from the date of the overpayment to try and get their money back. So, while that eight-week window might be closed, you're not completely in the clear if it was a significant amount.
FAQ: The Overpayment Edition
How to I know if my employer can take money back from my paycheck?
It depends on the situation. If it was a payroll error and it's been within the past eight weeks, they might be able to deduct it in small amounts.
How much can my employer take out of each paycheck?
No more than 12.5% of your gross wages, and it can't bring you below minimum wage.
What if I think the deduction is unfair?
Contact the New York State Department of Labor for assistance.
Is there a deadline for my employer to get their money back?
Yes, they generally have six years from the date of the overpayment.
Should I tell my employer if I think I was overpaid?
Yes, honesty is always the best policy. It can save you a lot of trouble down the road.
💡 This page may contain affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
