What is Selective Incorporation How Was It Applied In Mcdonald V. Chicago

People are currently reading this guide.

You Wanna Keep Your Bang-Bang? Buckle Up for Selective Incorporation!

The United States Constitution: a glorious document outlining the rights and responsibilities of our great nation. But what if you told me some parts of it were like a fancy club with a velvet rope? That's where things get interesting with selective incorporation.

Hold on, what's the velvet rope all about?

Imagine the Bill of Rights – the first ten amendments – as the VIP section of the Constitution. Originally, these amendments only applied to the federal government, leaving states to potentially make their own rules. No free speech in Kansas? No problem (according to some interpretations at the time, that is). This wasn't exactly the "liberty and justice for all" vibe we were going for.

Enter the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause, stage left.

This clause basically says states can't take away your life, liberty, or property without following proper procedures. But a clever bunch of legal minds realized, "Hey, maybe some Bill of Rights protections are essential for liberty!" Thus began the era of selective incorporation, where the Supreme Court, case by case, decided which Bill of Rights protections should apply to the states as well.

So, how did this fancy footwork play out in McDonald's v. Chicago?

In this 2010 case, Otis McDonald (yes, really) wasn't lovin' it when Chicago banned handguns. He argued that the Second Amendment's right to bear arms should be incorporated for the states through the Fourteenth Amendment.

The Court, building on a previous case called District of Columbia v. Heller, agreed. They ruled that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms for self-defense is fundamental (basically, super important) and therefore applies to the states. This was a big deal, because it meant states couldn't just shut down gun ownership entirely.

But wait, there's more!

Selective incorporation is a fascinating legal dance. It's the Supreme Court deciding which parts of the Constitution's VIP section everyone gets access to. It's not always a smooth waltz, and there's plenty of debate about which rights deserve to be incorporated. But one thing's for sure: it's a key part of how our federal and state governments work together to protect our liberties.

Remember, folks, knowing your legal rights is like having a plus one for the Constitution's VIP section. Just keep it civil, and maybe avoid bringing any McFlurries.

5374545255636239215

💡 This page may contain affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.


hows.tech

You have our undying gratitude for your visit!