So You Think You Can Law? A tongue-in-cheek look at Austin's Command Theory
Ever wondered why you shouldn't steal your neighbor's prize-winning tulips (besides the whole "being a decent human" thing)? Well, according to 19th-century legal scholar John Austin, it all boils down to one thing: you're breaking the rules of the schoolyard bully, but way fancier. Buckle up, because we're diving into the world of Austin's Command Theory of Law, where laws are basically orders barked by the big cheese in charge.
 |
| What is Austin's Command Theory Of Law |
The Big Kahuna: Who's the Sovereign, Anyway?
Imagine a playground, but instead of dodgeball, it's a whole society with laws. In Austin's theory, there's this top dog, the sovereign (think king, queen, parliament, or even a whole dang country!), who lays down the law. This sovereign isn't bossed around by anyone else, kind of like the kid who always gets to pick the game.
But wait, there's more! The sovereign doesn't just yell random commands. These gotta be general rules, applying to everyone, not just some pesky little Timmy who keeps kicking sand.
The Not-So-Subtle Persuader: The Power of Sanctions
Now, here's the kicker: these laws come with sanctions, which are basically the playground equivalent of getting your prized marbles confiscated. Sanctions can be anything from fines to jail time, depending on the severity of the rule-breaking. The idea is, this threat of punishment keeps everyone in line, even when the sovereign isn't watching (because, let's face it, that playground monitor can't be everywhere).
QuickTip: Slow down if the pace feels too fast.
Important Note: Austin wasn't a fan of positive reinforcement. Don't expect gold stars for following the rules. It's all about avoiding the dreaded sanction hammer.
So, is that it? Is Law Just Bossing People Around?
Well, not quite. Austin's theory has its limitations. For example, it doesn't really explain moral laws or international law, which don't always have a clear-cut sovereign figure. And let's be honest, some laws are more like suggestions than playground edicts (who actually follows the 2-second rule for dropped food?).
But hey, it's a good starting point! Austin's theory helped us think critically about what makes a law a law, and why we (generally) follow them.
QuickTip: Stop scrolling if you find value.
FAQ: Mastering the Playground (of Law)
How to identify the sovereign?
This can get tricky! It depends on the specific political system. Sometimes it's a monarch, other times it's a whole parliament. The key is to find the entity with the ultimate authority.
 |
How to deal with a sovereign who keeps changing the rules?
QuickTip: Scroll back if you lose track.
That's the fun part of law! Legal systems evolve over time. New laws get passed, old ones get repealed. It's a never-ending game of tag, but hopefully, the core principles of fairness and order stay in place.
How to handle situations without a clear sovereign (like international law)?
This is where things get fuzzy. Treaties and customary practices can play a role, but it's definitely more complex than a schoolyard showdown.
Tip: Make mental notes as you go.
How to avoid getting sanctioned?
The best advice? Follow the rules! (Unless they're super unfair, then maybe talk to a grown-up... I mean, a lawyer.)
How to become a legal scholar yourself?
Well, that takes a bit more than reading this post! But keep asking questions, be curious, and who knows, maybe you'll be the next Austin, redefining the law for future generations (or at least the next dodgeball game).
 |
