Where To Eat Pizza In Little Italy Nyc

People are currently reading this guide.

Little Italy: Where the Pie's the Prize

Little Italy, a tiny slice of Italy in the heart of the Big Apple, is a place where the aroma of garlic and basil lingers in the air like a warm embrace. It's a neighborhood that’s as famous for its red sauce joints as it is for its history. And, let's be honest, the real reason you're here isn't for the history – it's for the pizza.

A Slice of Heaven (or at least, New York)

Now, I know what you're thinking. "Little Italy? Pizza? Isn’t that like saying water is wet?" Well, yes, it’s pretty obvious, but trust me, there's a world of difference between good New York pizza and Little Italy pizza. It's like comparing a basic t-shirt to a designer one – same fabric, different vibe.

Little Italy pizza is a whole experience. It’s about the old-school charm, the checkered tablecloths, and the waiters who’ve been there longer than you’ve been alive. It’s about the thin, crispy crust that’s as light as a feather, yet sturdy enough to hold its own against a mountain of toppings. And it's about the sauce – that perfect blend of sweet and tangy that makes you want to lick the plate (but please, don't).

Where to Find Your Perfect Slice

So, where do you start? Well, that depends on what kind of pizza lover you are. Are you a classic cheese purist? Do you prefer your pizza loaded with everything but the kitchen sink? Or maybe you’re a deep-dish devotee (gasp!). Don’t worry, Little Italy has something for everyone.

  • Lombardi’s: This place is like the granddaddy of pizza. Claimed to be America’s first pizzeria, it’s a must-visit for any pizza pilgrimage. Just be prepared to wait – it’s that popular.
  • John’s of Bleecker Street: Another iconic spot, John’s is known for its coal-oven pizza. The crust is charred to perfection, and the cheese is gooey and delicious.
  • Prince Street Pizza: If you're after a more casual vibe, Prince Street Pizza is your place. This no-frills spot serves up massive slices that are perfect for sharing (or not).

Tips for a Perfect Pizza Experience

  • Arrive hungry: Little Italy pizza is not for the faint of heart.
  • Don’t be afraid to share: It’s a great way to try different slices.
  • Pace yourself: You’ll want to save room for dessert (cannoli, anyone?).
  • Embrace the chaos: Little Italy can be crowded, but it’s all part of the charm.

How To...

  • How to order like a local? Keep it simple: "One slice, please."
  • How to avoid the tourist traps? Do your research or ask a local.
  • How to find the best cannoli? Follow your nose (and maybe your taste buds).
  • How to survive the crowds? Go during off-peak hours or be prepared to wait.
  • How to experience the full Little Italy vibe? Walk around, people-watch, and soak it all in.
4320240812094653507

You have our undying gratitude for your visit!