Feeling a little unsure about your 401(k) and how it stacks up against everyone else's? You're not alone! Many people wonder if they're on track for a comfortable retirement or if they should be doing more. This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about comparing your 401(k) to others, understanding key metrics, and even improving its performance.
Let's dive in and see where you stand!
How Does My 401(k) Compare to Others? A Step-by-Step Guide
Comparing your 401(k) isn't just about looking at a number; it's about understanding the factors that influence its growth and identifying areas for optimization. Here’s how to do it systematically:
 |
| How Does My 401k Compare To Others |
Step 1: Gather Your 401(k) Data (It's Easier Than You Think!)
Before you can compare, you need to know what you're comparing! Don't let this step intimidate you. It's usually just a few clicks away.
What to Look For:
Current Balance: This is the total amount of money in your 401(k) right now.
Contribution Rate: How much of your salary are you contributing? This is often expressed as a percentage.
Employer Match: Does your employer contribute to your 401(k)? If so, what's their matching formula (e.g., 50 cents on the dollar up to 6% of your pay)?
Investment Holdings: What funds are you invested in? (e.g., target-date funds, stock funds, bond funds).
Fees: This is crucial but often overlooked. Look for administrative fees, recordkeeping fees, and expense ratios of the funds you hold. Your Form 5500 (annual report) or Summary Plan Description (SPD) can provide this information, or you can ask your plan administrator.
Vesting Schedule: How long do you need to work at your company before the employer's matching contributions become fully yours?
Where to Find It:
Your 401(k) Provider Website: Most providers (like Fidelity, Vanguard, Empower) have user-friendly online portals where you can access all this information.
Annual Statements: Your provider sends these out periodically.
HR Department/Plan Administrator: If you can't find specific details online, your HR department or the designated 401(k) plan administrator at your company can help.
Pro Tip: Download or print out your latest statement. Having a physical copy or a digital file readily accessible will make the comparison process much smoother.
Step 2: Benchmark Your Balance Against Age and Income Averages
Once you have your own data, the first thing many people want to know is, "Am I on track?" While averages are just that – averages – they can provide a useful gauge.
Understanding Average vs. Median:
You'll often see both "average" and "median" balances.
The average can be skewed by a few very high earners.
The median represents the midpoint, meaning half of the people have more, and half have less. The median is often a more realistic benchmark for the typical saver.
General Benchmarks by Age (Based on recent data from Vanguard and Fidelity):
Age Range | Average 401(k) Balance | Median 401(k) Balance | Fidelity's Recommended Savings (Multiple of Salary) Tip: Reading on mobile? Zoom in for better comfort. |
Under 25 | $6,899 - $7,351 | $1,948 - $2,816 | Not explicitly stated, focus on starting |
25-34 | $42,640 - $37,557 | $14,933 - $16,255 | 1x Salary by Age 30 |
35-44 | $103,552 - $91,281 | $35,537 - $39,958 | 3x Salary by Age 40 |
45-54 | $188,643 - $168,646 | $60,763 - $67,796 | 6x Salary by Age 50 |
55-64 | $271,320 - $244,750 | $87,571 - $95,642 | 8x Salary by Age 60 |
65+ | $299,442 - $272,588 | $88,488 - $95,425 | 10x Salary by Age 67 Tip: Pause, then continue with fresh focus. |
Note: These are general guidelines. Your personal financial situation, desired retirement lifestyle, and overall health will influence your individual savings goals.
How to Use This Data:
Find your age range.
Compare your actual balance to both the average and median.
Consider your income. If you earn significantly more than the average for your age group, you might aim for a higher balance.
Look at the "multiple of salary" benchmarks. This is a powerful way to assess if you're saving enough relative to your earnings. For example, if you're 40 and earn $75,000, Fidelity suggests having $225,000 saved (3x salary).
Step 3: Evaluate Your Employer Match (Free Money Alert!)
This is arguably the most important factor when comparing 401(k) plans. An employer match is essentially free money for your retirement.
What to Compare:
Matching Formula: What percentage of your contribution does your employer match, and up to what percentage of your salary?
Example: A common match is 50 cents on the dollar up to 6% of your pay. This means if you contribute 6% of your salary, your employer contributes another 3%.
Vesting Schedule: How long until the employer's contributions are 100% yours? Some plans have immediate vesting, while others have a graded schedule (e.g., 20% vested each year for 5 years) or a cliff vesting (100% vested after a certain number of years, typically 3).
Why it Matters:
Significant Boost: Maximizing your employer match can dramatically accelerate your retirement savings. It's a guaranteed return on your investment right from the start.
Leaving Money on the Table: If you're not contributing enough to get the full match, you're literally passing up free money.
Action Item: Ensure you are contributing at least enough to get your full employer match. If you aren't, this should be your first priority for increasing your contributions.
Step 4: Scrutinize Your 401(k) Fees (The Silent Killer of Returns)
Fees, even seemingly small ones, can devastate your long-term returns due to the power of compound interest working against you.
Types of Fees to Look For:
Administrative/Recordkeeping Fees: These cover the costs of managing the plan. They can be a flat dollar amount or a percentage of your assets.
Investment Management Fees (Expense Ratios): This is the most common fee and is charged by the mutual funds or ETFs you're invested in. It's expressed as a percentage of your assets (e.g., 0.50% or 1%).
Transaction Fees: Fees for buying or selling funds (less common in 401(k)s now).
Advisory Fees: If your plan includes an advisor, you might be paying for their services.
What's a "Good" Fee?
Expense Ratios: Aim for under 0.50% for passively managed index funds or ETFs. Actively managed funds might be higher, but generally, lower is better. An average 401(k) plan might have an expense ratio around 1%.
Total "All-in" Fees: Some calculators combine all fees. Ideally, your total annual fees should be below 1% of your account balance.
How to Compare:
Online Fee Calculators: Websites like BrightScope or Employee Fiduciary offer tools to compare your plan's fees to industry averages.
Form 5500: Your plan's annual report, Form 5500, can detail the fees being charged.
Remember: A 1% difference in fees over 20-30 years can cost you tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in lost returns.
Step 5: Assess Your Investment Options and Performance
The quality and variety of investment options within your 401(k) directly impact your potential for growth.
Tip: Read aloud to improve understanding.
What to Look For:
Variety of Funds: Does your plan offer a good selection of funds across different asset classes (stocks, bonds, cash)?
Low-Cost Index Funds/ETFs: These typically offer broad market exposure with very low expense ratios.
Target-Date Funds: These "set it and forget it" funds automatically adjust their asset allocation as you get closer to retirement. Check their expense ratios.
Fund Performance: How have the funds available to you performed historically compared to their benchmarks (e.g., S&P 500 for a large-cap stock fund)? Use resources like Morningstar to check fund ratings and performance.
Average Annual Return: A typical 401(k) with a moderately aggressive portfolio (e.g., 60% stocks, 40% bonds) might expect an average annual return of 5% to 8% over the long term. This can vary significantly based on market conditions and your asset allocation.
How to Compare:
Morningstar Ratings: Look up the mutual funds in your 401(k) on Morningstar. They provide star ratings and analyst ratings (Gold, Silver, Bronze) that can indicate quality.
Compare to Benchmarks: See how your chosen funds perform against relevant market indices. Don't be surprised if your fund's return lags the index by 1-2% due to fees.
Important Note: Past performance is not indicative of future results, but consistent underperformance might be a red flag.
Step 6: Consider Your Personal Circumstances and Goals
Comparing your 401(k) isn't just about external benchmarks; it's about your unique situation.
Key Questions to Ask Yourself:
Risk Tolerance: How comfortable are you with market fluctuations? This should influence your asset allocation. Younger investors typically have a higher risk tolerance.
Time Horizon: How many years until you plan to retire? A longer time horizon allows for more aggressive investments and time to recover from downturns.
Other Savings: Do you have other retirement accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, brokerage accounts)? Your 401(k) is just one piece of your overall retirement puzzle.
Desired Retirement Lifestyle: What kind of retirement do you envision? This will dictate how much you ultimately need to save.
Income and Savings Capacity: Can you realistically increase your contributions?
Step 7: Take Action Based on Your Findings
Once you've done your homework, it's time to make adjustments if necessary.
If Your 401(k) Compares Favorably:
Great job! Keep up the good work with regular contributions and periodic reviews.
Consider increasing your contributions if your budget allows, especially if you're not yet maxing out the annual IRS limits.
If Your 401(k) is Underperforming or Has High Fees:
Contact Your Plan Administrator/HR:
Inquire about lower-cost investment options.
Ask about reducing administrative fees.
Suggest adding better-performing funds or index funds.
Highlight competitor offerings (if you have them).
Adjust Your Contributions: If you're not getting the full employer match, increase your contributions to at least that level.
Rebalance Your Portfolio: Ensure your asset allocation aligns with your risk tolerance and time horizon.
Diversify: Make sure your investments are spread across different types of assets to reduce risk.
Consider Other Retirement Accounts: If your 401(k) is truly subpar and your employer match is limited, you might consider contributing to a Roth IRA or Traditional IRA after maximizing your 401(k) match. IRAs often offer a wider selection of investments and potentially lower fees.
Remember: Even small improvements to your 401(k) now can lead to substantial gains over the decades.
10 Related FAQ Questions
How to calculate my 401(k) rate of return?
To calculate your personal rate of return, you generally need to account for your contributions, withdrawals, and the investment gains or losses. Your 401(k) provider statement usually provides a "personal rate of return" or "time-weighted return" for various periods, which is the easiest way to see it.
Tip: Read once for gist, twice for details.
How to find out my 401(k) fees?
Check your annual 401(k) statements, Summary Plan Description (SPD), or Form 5500. You can also directly ask your HR department or 401(k) plan administrator for a detailed breakdown of all fees.
How to know if my 401(k) employer match is good?
An employer match is considered good if it's 4% or more of your salary, especially if it's a dollar-for-dollar match. The average match is around 4.5% of salary.
How to compare my 401(k) to other companies' plans?
You can use online tools provided by financial research firms like BrightScope or Morningstar, or specialized 401(k) benchmarking services. These tools allow you to compare various aspects like fees, investment options, and employer matches.
How to improve my 401(k) performance?
Improve performance by maximizing your employer match, lowering fees (by choosing low-cost funds), diversifying your investments, regularly rebalancing your portfolio, and considering dollar-cost averaging (consistent contributions regardless of market ups and downs).
How to choose the right investments within my 401(k)?
Consider your age and risk tolerance. Younger investors can typically opt for more aggressive growth funds (more stocks), while those nearing retirement should shift towards more conservative options (more bonds and cash). Target-date funds are a popular "set it and forget it" option.
How to increase my 401(k) contribution rate?
Log into your 401(k) provider's website or contact your HR department. You can usually change your contribution percentage or dollar amount at any time. Aim to increase it by at least 1% annually, especially after a raise.
How to understand 401(k) vesting schedules?
Vesting schedules dictate when the employer's contributions truly become yours. With "immediate vesting," it's yours right away. "Graded vesting" means you become gradually vested over several years (e.g., 20% per year). "Cliff vesting" means you become 100% vested after a specific period (e.g., 3 years).
How to know if my 401(k) is too aggressive or too conservative?
A general rule of thumb (Rule of 100 or 110) suggests subtracting your age from 100 or 110 to determine the percentage of your portfolio that should be in stocks. For example, a 30-year-old might have 70-80% in stocks. If your allocation deviates significantly, it might be too aggressive or conservative for your stage of life.
How to roll over an old 401(k) into a new one or an IRA?
Contact the administrator of your old 401(k) or your new 401(k) provider/IRA provider. They will guide you through the direct rollover process, which ensures the funds are transferred directly without incurring taxes or penalties.
 |
