Hey there! Ever found yourself scrolling through Reddit, seeing countless discussions about banking and wondering, "How is Marcus by Goldman Sachs really doing?" You're not alone! Many people turn to the unfiltered opinions of fellow users on Reddit to get a real sense of a financial product. And when it comes to Marcus by Goldman Sachs, the opinions are definitely varied.
This comprehensive guide will delve deep into what Reddit users are saying about Marcus, covering everything from their popular High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs) and CDs to personal loans and customer service. We'll break down the common themes, the good, the bad, and the downright frustrating, to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding Marcus by Goldman Sachs
Before we dive into the Reddit chatter, let's briefly understand what Marcus is. Marcus by Goldman Sachs is the consumer banking arm of the well-known investment bank, Goldman Sachs. It was launched to offer simpler, more accessible financial products to individuals, primarily focusing on:
High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs): These accounts offer significantly higher interest rates than traditional savings accounts.
Certificates of Deposit (CDs): Time-deposit accounts that typically offer fixed interest rates for a set period.
Personal Loans: Unsecured loans often used for debt consolidation or large purchases.
Now, let's see what the Reddit community has to say!
 |
| How Is Marcus By Goldman Sachs Reddit |
Step 1: Diving into the Reddit Hive Mind – What's the General Vibe?
Ready to explore the real talk? The first step to understanding Marcus on Reddit is to get a general feel for the sentiment. Head over to subreddits like r/personalfinance, r/Banking, r/MarcusInvest, and r/Money. Use the search bar for terms like "Marcus by Goldman Sachs," "Marcus HYSA," "Marcus loan," or "Marcus CD."
You'll quickly notice a pattern: Marcus tends to evoke strong opinions. Some users swear by it, praising its high interest rates and simplicity, while others recount frustrating experiences, particularly concerning funds being held or customer service issues.
QuickTip: Reflect before moving to the next part.
Sub-heading: The Good, The Bad, and The "Meh"
The Good: High Yields and Simplicity
High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs): Many Reddit users initially flock to Marcus for its competitive APY (Annual Percentage Yield). You'll see comments like, "I've been using Marcus for years now and it's been good. The interest rates are all the same (they're all linked to the fed funds rate and they'll all adjust to match each other within a few days whenever the rate changes). So, it doesn't matter which you pi
ck." Users appreciate getting a better return on their emergency funds or savings compared to traditional banks. User Interface: The mobile app and website are often described as clean and easy to navigate, focusing purely on savings and basic transactions, which many find refreshing.
FDIC Insurance: A common reassuring point is that Marcus accounts are FDIC insured, meaning your deposits are protected up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category. This provides a sense of security, especially for those holding significant savings.
The Bad: The Infamous "Account Review" and Customer Service
Fund Holds and Account Freezes: This is by far the most frequently cited complaint on Reddit. Numerous users report their accounts being frozen or transfers being held for extended periods, often under the guise of "identity verification" or "fraud detection." This can be incredibly disruptive, especially when large sums of money are involved, as seen in posts like, "Marcus at Goldman Sachs has put the account under review and now the money cant be used: how to get the account released." The frustration stems from a perceived lack of transparency and an inability to get clear answers or quick resolutions from customer service.
Customer Service Challenges: Related to the above, Reddit threads are rife with complaints about Marcus's customer service. Users describe it as "unhelpful," "slow," and a "labyrinth of incompetency." Phrases like, "Customer service is filled with some of the dumbest people on earth. My lord, I'm just trying to send my 13k back to where it was funded from...but Marcus is THE WORST, absolute nightmare can't wait to close my account," are unfortunately common.
Limited Services: Some users express frustration that Marcus is only a savings/CD/loan platform and doesn't offer checking accounts or a broader suite of banking services. This means you'll likely need another primary bank for daily transactions.
The "Meh": Interest Rate Chasing and Referral Fatigue
Rate Fluctuations: While HYSAs offer competitive rates, these rates do fluctuate with the market. Some users on Reddit are constantly "rate chasing," moving their money to whatever bank offers the highest current APY, and Marcus's rate isn't always the top performer.
Referral Code Overload: For a while, Reddit was flooded with Marcus referral codes, offering small bonuses to new users. While beneficial, it also led to some "referral fatigue" and made it harder to find genuine reviews amidst the promotions.
Step 2: Analyzing Specific Product Feedback
Now that you have a general sense, let's zoom in on the specific products offered by Marcus and what Reddit users are saying about each.
Sub-heading: High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs)
The Marcus HYSA is arguably their most popular offering.
Pros from Reddit:
High APY: As mentioned, this is the primary draw. Users love seeing their savings grow more quickly.
No Fees: Marcus HYSAs typically have no monthly maintenance fees or minimum balance requirements, which is a big plus for many.
Ease of Opening: The online application process is generally considered straightforward.
Cons from Reddit:
Transfer Delays and Holds: This is the biggest pain point. When large sums are transferred in or out, especially if they've recently been moved from another bank, Marcus's fraud detection can trigger holds, leaving users unable to access their funds for days or even weeks. This leads to comments like, "If you're using it as an emergency fund, make sure you have other liquid funds readily available, as pulling money out quickly can be a nightmare."
Identity Verification Issues: Some users report difficulties with identity verification, even after providing requested documents, leading to account lockouts.
Sub-heading: Certificates of Deposit (CDs)
Marcus also offers various CD terms.
Tip: Let the key ideas stand out.
Pros from Reddit:
Competitive Rates: Similar to HYSAs, Marcus often offers attractive CD rates, especially on their no-penalty CDs.
FDIC Insured: The same FDIC insurance applies to CDs, providing security for the locked-up funds.
Predictable Returns: For those looking to lock in a rate for a set period, Marcus CDs are seen as a reliable option.
Cons from Reddit:
Early Withdrawal Penalties: While they offer "no-penalty" CDs, traditional CDs come with penalties for early withdrawal, which some users forget or find restrictive.
Less Discussion: Compared to HYSAs, there's generally less detailed discussion about Marcus CDs on Reddit, perhaps because they're a more "set it and forget it" product. However, some users still report the same transfer and verification issues when CDs mature and they try to move funds.
Sub-heading: Personal Loans
Marcus offers personal loans, often for debt consolidation.
Pros from Reddit:
Competitive Rates (for qualified borrowers): Users with good credit scores often report receiving competitive interest rates compared to credit cards or other lenders.
Pre-qualification with Soft Pull: Marcus allows you to check your rate with a soft credit inquiry, which doesn't impact your credit score, before committing to a full application. This is a highly valued feature on Reddit.
Streamlined Application Process: Many find the application process to be relatively quick and efficient.
Cons from Reddit:
Strict Eligibility: Some users with less-than-perfect credit may find it challenging to qualify for the best rates or even get approved.
Loan Purpose Restrictions: While flexible, personal loans are best suited for specific purposes like debt consolidation, and users are advised to be clear on their financial goals.
Step 3: Evaluating the Reddit Consensus and Red Flags
As you sift through the various threads, certain themes will become apparent.
Sub-heading: Key Takeaways from Reddit
*Excellent for Steady Savings: If you're looking for a place to park your emergency fund or long-term savings where you won't need frequent access to large sums, Marcus's HYSA is often praised for its interest rates.
*Proceed with Caution for Large or Frequent Transfers: This is the biggest red flag. If you anticipate needing to move substantial amounts of money in or out frequently, especially from new external accounts, be prepared for potential delays and intense verification processes. Many users advise against using Marcus for money that needs to be accessed quickly for time-sensitive transactions like real estate closings.
*Customer Service is a Weak Point: The general consensus on Reddit is that Marcus's customer service can be frustrating and unhelpful, particularly when dealing with account holds or complex issues.
**FDIC Insurance Provides Peace of Mind: Regardless of the operational frustrations, the fact that deposits are FDIC insured is a significant reassurance for users concerned about the safety of their funds.
Step 4: Deciding if Marcus is Right for You
Tip: Read once for flow, once for detail.
Based on the aggregated Reddit sentiment, here's how to decide if Marcus aligns with your financial needs:
Consider Marcus if:
You are primarily looking for a high-yield savings account or CD for long-term savings that you don't anticipate needing to access frequently or in large, sudden amounts.
You prioritize competitive interest rates over a full suite of banking services.
You are comfortable with online-only banking and don't require in-person branch support.
You have a secondary checking account at another bank for daily transactions and bill payments.
Think Twice or Have a Backup Plan if:
You need immediate and frequent access to large sums of money.
You are easily frustrated by customer service challenges or lengthy verification processes.
You prefer a bank with a physical presence or a more comprehensive range of services (e.g., checking accounts, wealth management all in one place).
You are planning a large, time-sensitive transaction soon that requires quick access to your funds.
Step 5: Practical Steps for Engaging with Marcus (and Managing Expectations)
If you decide to proceed with Marcus, here are some practical tips gleaned from Reddit users' experiences:
Sub-heading: Opening an Account
Do your research on current rates: Rates fluctuate, so check Marcus's website and compare them with other top HYSA providers like Ally, Discover, or Capital One 360. Reddit threads often have discussions comparing current rates.
Use a referral code (if available and you choose to): Many users share referral codes that offer a small APY boost for a few months. Search Reddit for "Marcus referral" to find current codes. However, be mindful that these are from other users and not directly from Marcus.
Start with a smaller transfer: If you're nervous about potential holds, consider an initial smaller transfer to test the waters and ensure everything links correctly before moving a substantial amount.
Sub-heading: Managing Your Account
Link external accounts carefully: Ensure the bank account you link for transfers is in your name and that all information matches perfectly to avoid verification delays.
Plan large withdrawals in advance: If you know you'll need a significant amount of money from your Marcus HYSA, initiate the transfer well in advance of when you need the funds. Allow for several business days, and potentially longer if any holds occur.
Keep records: As some Reddit users advise, keep detailed records of all communication with Marcus customer service, especially if you encounter issues. This includes dates, times, representative names, and summaries of conversations.
Consider the CFPB: If you experience severe issues with fund access or unhelpful customer service, some Reddit users have found success by filing a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). This can sometimes escalate your case.
10 Related FAQ Questions
QuickTip: Compare this post with what you already know.
Here are 10 "How to" FAQs based on common Reddit queries about Marcus by Goldman Sachs, with quick answers:
How to open a Marcus by Goldman Sachs High-Yield Savings Account? You can open a Marcus HYSA directly on their website. You'll need to provide personal information, including your Social Security number, and link an external bank account for initial funding.
How to transfer money into a Marcus HYSA? You can transfer funds into your Marcus HYSA via ACH transfer from a linked external bank account, or by setting up direct deposit from your payroll.
How to withdraw money from a Marcus HYSA quickly? While ACH transfers are the standard, quicker options are limited. Marcus generally processes ACH transfers within 1-3 business days. For very large or time-sensitive withdrawals, some users on Reddit suggest having a backup fund or a primary bank with stronger instant transfer capabilities.
How to avoid account freezes or holds with Marcus? The best way is to ensure all linked account information is accurate and consistent. Avoid frequent large transfers, especially immediately after linking a new external account. If you anticipate a large transfer, consider contacting Marcus customer service beforehand to inform them.
How to contact Marcus by Goldman Sachs customer service effectively? Reddit users often recommend being persistent, keeping detailed notes of all calls, and asking for escalation if your issue isn't resolved by the initial representative. Filing a CFPB complaint is also an option for severe issues.
How to earn the highest interest rate with Marcus? Marcus's interest rates are variable and tied to market conditions. You can also get a temporary APY boost through referral codes if available from existing users.
How to close a Marcus by Goldman Sachs account? You can typically initiate an account closure through their online platform or by contacting customer service directly. Ensure all funds are withdrawn before requesting closure.
How to apply for a Marcus personal loan? You can apply online through the Marcus website. They offer a pre-qualification process that allows you to check your rate without impacting your credit score.
How to find Marcus by Goldman Sachs referral codes? Search on Reddit in relevant finance or Marcus-specific subreddits. Users frequently post their referral links, which offer a temporary APY boost for new sign-ups.
How to check if Marcus by Goldman Sachs is FDIC insured? Yes, Marcus by Goldman Sachs is FDIC insured. This means your deposits are protected up to the legal limit of $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category, in the unlikely event of bank failure.
 |
