Understanding the Foundation: What is a Private Letter Ruling?
Before we dive into the "how-to," let's solidify what a Private Letter Ruling truly is.
A Private Letter Ruling (PLR) is a written statement issued by the IRS to a taxpayer, interpreting and applying tax laws to the taxpayer's specific set of facts. It's a binding determination, meaning the IRS is bound by its decision as long as you've accurately and fully presented your situation in the request.
Key characteristics of a PLR:
- Specific to the Taxpayer: A PLR applies only to the taxpayer who requested it and to the specific facts described in the request. You cannot rely on a PLR issued to another taxpayer as precedent.
- Binding on the IRS: If you accurately describe your facts and carry out the transaction as described, the IRS must follow its ruling.
- Provides Certainty: The primary benefit of a PLR is to remove uncertainty about the tax consequences of a particular transaction before it's completed or before your tax return is filed. This is particularly valuable for complex or high-stakes transactions.
- Publicly Available (with redactions): While a PLR is issued to a specific taxpayer, it is generally made public after all identifying information about the taxpayer has been removed. These redacted PLRs can be valuable research tools for other taxpayers and their advisors, as they offer insight into the IRS's thinking on various tax issues, even if they aren't directly binding.
 |
| How To Get A Private Letter Ruling From The Irs |
When to Consider a PLR
A PLR isn't for every tax question. It's generally pursued when:
- The tax law related to your situation is unclear or ambiguous.
- There's a significant financial impact riding on the tax treatment of a particular transaction.
- Published guidance (like regulations, revenue rulings, or notices) doesn't directly address your specific facts.
- You need assurance from the IRS regarding the tax consequences before you proceed with a transaction.
The Journey to Certainty: A Step-by-Step Guide to Getting a Private Letter Ruling
Obtaining a PLR is a meticulous process that requires thorough preparation and adherence to strict IRS procedures. Let's break it down:
Step 1: Is a PLR Even Necessary for You? (The Crucial Self-Assessment)
Before you embark on this often time-consuming and costly endeavor, pause and ask yourself: Do I truly need a Private Letter Ruling?
Tip: Reading twice doubles clarity.
Many tax questions can be answered by consulting published IRS guidance, seeking advice from a qualified tax professional (like a CPA or tax attorney), or even by reviewing existing PLRs that, while not binding, may offer strong indications of the IRS's position on similar issues.
- Consider these questions:
- Is the law unclear? If there's a straightforward answer in the Internal Revenue Code, regulations, or a definitive revenue ruling, a PLR is likely unnecessary.
- Is a tax opinion from a professional sufficient? For many situations, a well-reasoned tax opinion from an attorney or accountant can provide enough comfort. This is often a less expensive and faster alternative.
- What's the potential tax liability at stake? PLRs are expensive. If the tax dollars involved are small, the cost of a PLR might outweigh the benefit.
- Is this a hypothetical situation? The IRS generally does not issue PLRs on hypothetical situations or questions that don't involve your tax status, liability, or reporting obligations.
- Is the issue already under examination, consideration, or litigation by the IRS? The IRS typically won't issue a PLR on an issue that's already being reviewed.
If you've carefully considered these points and still believe a PLR is the best path forward, then proceed to the next step!
Step 2: Research and Due Diligence (Laying the Groundwork)
This is where you become a tax detective. Thorough research is paramount to a successful PLR request.
Sub-heading 2.1: Consult the Annual Revenue Procedure
The IRS publishes an annual revenue procedure (typically Revenue Procedure 202X-1 at the beginning of each calendar year, where "202X" is the current year) that outlines the detailed procedures for requesting PLRs and other types of guidance. This document is your bible for the PLR process. It includes:
- User Fee Schedule: The cost of a PLR can be substantial, ranging from a few thousand dollars to tens of thousands, depending on the complexity of the issue and the taxpayer's income. For 2025, the general user fee for a PLR is $43,700, though reduced fees apply for smaller taxpayers and certain requests.
- Sample Request Letter Templates: These are invaluable for structuring your request.
- Checklist: A comprehensive checklist of over 50 questions that must be answered in your request. Do NOT skip this checklist.
- Areas Where the IRS Will Not Rule: The revenue procedure also lists topics on which the IRS generally will not issue a PLR. Make sure your issue isn't on this "no-rule" list.
Sub-heading 2.2: Review Published Guidance and Existing PLRs
- IRS Website and Publications: Explore the IRS website (irs.gov) for existing regulations, revenue rulings, notices, and other official guidance that might be relevant to your situation.
- PLR Databases: Many legal and tax research platforms (like Bloomberg Tax, Thomson Reuters Checkpoint, Westlaw, LexisNexis, etc.) maintain databases of redacted PLRs. While not binding precedent, studying similar PLRs can provide valuable insights into the IRS's analytical approach and the types of facts they consider important.
Step 3: Pre-Submission Conference (Optional, but Recommended)
For complex issues, considering a pre-submission conference with the IRS Office of Chief Counsel can be highly beneficial.
QuickTip: Focus on what feels most relevant.
Sub-heading 3.1: The Benefits of a Pre-Submission Conference
- Clarify Issues: You can discuss the issues with IRS attorneys without revealing your identity (or your client's identity) initially.
- Gauge IRS Interest: It helps determine if the IRS is willing to rule on your specific issue.
- Narrow the Scope: You can work with the IRS to refine the issues to be addressed in the PLR, potentially simplifying your request.
- Understand IRS Concerns: The IRS attorneys might provide informal, non-binding views and flag any potential problematic aspects of your proposed transaction.
Sub-heading 3.2: How to Arrange a Pre-Submission Conference
The annual revenue procedure details how to request a pre-submission conference. Generally, you'll submit a brief, anonymous outline of the proposed transaction and the issues involved.
Step 4: Drafting Your Private Letter Ruling Request (The Core of Your Application)
This is the most critical and labor-intensive step. Your PLR request must be meticulously drafted, complete, and fully compliant with all procedural requirements outlined in the annual revenue procedure. Any omissions or errors can lead to delays or even a rejection of your request.
Sub-heading 4.1: Essential Elements of Your Request Letter
Your PLR request should be structured clearly and logically, typically including the following sections:
- Introduction: State that you are requesting a private letter ruling and briefly describe the transaction or issue.
- Statement of Facts: This is paramount. Provide a complete, detailed, and accurate statement of all relevant facts.
- Include dates, names of parties, copies of all relevant documents (contracts, wills, trust agreements, etc.).
- Crucially, represent that all facts are true and correct to the best of your knowledge and belief, and that the transaction has not yet been consummated (or if it has, why a ruling is still appropriate).
- The IRS will rely solely on the facts you present. Any material omission or misrepresentation could invalidate the ruling.
- Statement of Law and Analysis: This section demonstrates your legal analysis of the issue.
- Cite relevant sections of the Internal Revenue Code, Treasury Regulations, revenue rulings, court cases, and other applicable guidance.
- Explain how these authorities apply to your specific facts and support the ruling you are requesting.
- Don't just state the law; apply it to your unique circumstances.
- Rulings Requested: Clearly and concisely state the specific rulings you are seeking from the IRS. These should be framed as direct questions that the IRS can answer with a "yes" or "no" or a definitive statement.
- Example: "Will XYZ transaction, as described above, qualify as a tax-free reorganization under Section 368(a)(1)(D) of the Internal Revenue Code?"
- Procedural Matters and Required Representations: This section includes various statements and declarations required by the IRS. The annual revenue procedure provides a comprehensive list, which typically includes:
- A declaration that the same issue is not currently under examination, before appeals, or in litigation with the IRS.
- A statement regarding whether a similar request has been filed previously.
- A statement regarding whether the taxpayer is requesting expedited treatment (and the justification for it, if applicable).
- A power of attorney (Form 2848) if you are being represented by a tax professional.
- A penalties of perjury statement, signed by the taxpayer.
- Statement of Proposed Deletions: Because PLRs are eventually made public (with redactions), you must submit a separate statement proposing which information should be deleted to protect your privacy and proprietary information.
- Be specific about what you want redacted and explain why its disclosure would cause harm (e.g., trade secrets, financial information that would identify you).
Sub-heading 4.2: Attention to Detail and Clarity
- Be precise and unambiguous. Avoid vague language.
- Organize your request logically with clear headings and subheadings.
- Proofread meticulously for any grammatical errors, typos, or factual inconsistencies.
- Consider engaging a tax professional (an attorney or CPA specializing in tax law) to assist with drafting. Their expertise in IRS procedures and tax law can be invaluable.
Step 5: Submitting Your Request (The Formal Lodging)
Once your comprehensive PLR request is drafted, it's time to submit it to the IRS.
 |
Sub-heading 5.1: Payment of the User Fee
- As mentioned, a substantial user fee is required. This fee must be submitted with your request. The exact amount depends on your income and the specific type of ruling requested, as detailed in the annual revenue procedure.
- As of the latest information (early 2025), the general fee is $43,700, with reduced fees for smaller taxpayers.
Sub-heading 5.2: Mailing Your Request
The annual revenue procedure will specify the correct mailing address for PLR requests. Ensure all required documents are included and properly assembled. Consider using certified mail with a return receipt for proof of delivery.
Tip: Revisit this page tomorrow to reinforce memory.
Step 6: The IRS Review Process (The Waiting Game and Interaction)
After submission, your request enters the IRS review pipeline. This process can take several months, sometimes longer, depending on the complexity and current IRS workload.
Sub-heading 6.1: Assignment to a Docket Attorney
Your request will be assigned to a "docket attorney" in the Office of Chief Counsel. This attorney will be your primary contact throughout the process.
Sub-heading 6.2: Initial Review and Information Requests
The docket attorney will review your request. It's common for them to:
- Request additional information: They may need further facts or clarification on details you've provided. You typically have 21 days to respond to such requests.
- Request additional legal analysis: They might ask for further analysis of specific legal points.
- Suggest modifications to your proposed rulings: The attorney may suggest rephrasing your requested rulings to better align with the IRS's practices.
Sub-heading 6.3: Conferences and Discussions
You (or your representative) will likely have conferences or phone calls with the docket attorney to discuss your request, clarify issues, and work towards a mutually agreeable ruling. This iterative process is crucial for a successful outcome.
Sub-heading 6.4: Draft Ruling Review
Once the IRS has completed its analysis and is prepared to issue a ruling, they may provide you with a draft of the proposed ruling. This is your opportunity to review the ruling for factual accuracy and ensure it addresses all your requested points.
Tip: Patience makes reading smoother.
Step 7: Receiving Your Private Letter Ruling (The Outcome)
Finally, after the rigorous review process, you will receive your official Private Letter Ruling.
Sub-heading 7.1: The Final PLR Document
The ruling will formally state the IRS's position on how the tax law applies to your specific facts. It will also include:
- A summary of your facts.
- The relevant legal authorities.
- The IRS's analysis.
- The specific rulings.
Sub-heading 7.2: What if the Ruling is Unfavorable?
If the IRS indicates an unfavorable ruling, you typically have the opportunity to withdraw your request. While you will forfeit the user fee, withdrawing may be preferable to receiving an unfavorable ruling that could be used against you in a future audit.
Step 8: Post-Ruling Considerations (Beyond the Issuance)
Even after receiving your PLR, there are a few things to keep in mind.
Sub-heading 8.1: Implementing the Transaction
Ensure that the actual transaction or action you undertake exactly matches the facts and circumstances described in your PLR request. Any material deviation could invalidate the ruling.
Sub-heading 8.2: Supplemental PLRs
If facts change significantly after a PLR has been issued, you may need to request a supplemental PLR to reconfirm the original ruling or obtain new rulings based on the changed facts.
Sub-heading 8.3: Potential Revocation or Modification
While PLRs are generally binding, the IRS can revoke or modify a previously issued PLR under certain circumstances, such as:
- If there was a material misstatement or omission of facts in your request.
- If the underlying law changes (e.g., through new legislation, regulations, or Supreme Court decisions).
- If the IRS determines the ruling was incorrect or inconsistent with its current position.
However, the IRS typically limits the retroactive effect of a revocation or modification, especially if you relied on the ruling in good faith.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Obtaining a Private Letter Ruling
Advantages:
- Tax Certainty: The primary benefit. A PLR provides a definitive answer from the IRS on how a complex or ambiguous tax issue will be treated for your specific situation. This certainty can be invaluable for making informed business or personal financial decisions.
- Avoidance of Penalties: By obtaining a PLR, you significantly reduce the risk of future audits, assessments, and penalties related to the specific issue covered by the ruling.
- Planning Tool: PLRs allow you to structure transactions or operations in a way that minimizes adverse tax consequences, knowing the IRS's position beforehand.
- Guidance for Future Decisions: While not directly binding on others, published PLRs can offer valuable insights into the IRS's approach to similar issues, helping other taxpayers and their advisors in their own planning.
Disadvantages:
- Cost: PLRs are expensive, involving not only the IRS user fee (which can be tens of thousands of dollars) but also significant professional fees for tax attorneys or CPAs to prepare the detailed request.
- Time-Consuming: The process can take several months, sometimes even longer for complex issues. This can be a drawback if you need a quick resolution.
- Limited Applicability: A PLR is binding only on the taxpayer who requested it and only for the specific facts presented. It cannot be used as precedent by other taxpayers.
- Risk of Unfavorable Ruling: There's no guarantee the IRS will rule in your favor. If the ruling is unfavorable, it could complicate your tax position, though you typically have the option to withdraw the request before it's formally issued.
- Disclosure: While identifying information is redacted, the core facts and legal analysis of your situation will become publicly available.
- Strict Adherence to Facts: Any material deviation from the facts presented in your request could invalidate the ruling, meaning you might have to start the process over or face a different tax outcome.
10 Related FAQ Questions
How to determine if a Private Letter Ruling is necessary for my situation?
- You should consider a PLR if your tax situation involves complex, unusual facts not clearly addressed by existing IRS guidance, and the tax implications are significant enough to warrant the substantial cost and time investment.
How to find the current user fees for a Private Letter Ruling?
- The current user fees are published annually by the IRS in a revenue procedure, typically Revenue Procedure 20XX-1 (where XX is the current year), released at the beginning of each calendar year. This document is available on the IRS website.
How to ensure my Private Letter Ruling request includes all required information?
- Carefully review the annual revenue procedure (e.g., Revenue Procedure 2025-1) issued by the IRS. It contains a detailed checklist of over 50 items and specific formatting requirements that must be followed.
How to prepare the "Statement of Proposed Deletions" for a Private Letter Ruling?
- You must submit a separate statement indicating which portions of your request you want redacted before the PLR is made public, along with a justification for each proposed deletion (e.g., trade secrets, personal financial information).
How to respond if the IRS requests additional information for my Private Letter Ruling request?
- The IRS typically provides a deadline (often 21 days) to respond to requests for additional information. Gather the requested details promptly and submit them in writing, referencing your original request.
How to get expedited treatment for a Private Letter Ruling request?
- The annual revenue procedure outlines the specific criteria for requesting expedited treatment. You must demonstrate a compelling business need for an accelerated ruling and provide a justification in your request.
How to withdraw a Private Letter Ruling request if the IRS indicates an unfavorable outcome?
- You can typically withdraw your request at any point before the ruling is formally issued. Contact the assigned IRS docket attorney in writing to formally withdraw the request. Note that user fees are generally not refunded upon withdrawal.
How to know if a Private Letter Ruling applies to my specific situation?
- A PLR only applies to the taxpayer who requested it and to the precise facts and circumstances described in the ruling request. Other taxpayers cannot rely on it as legal precedent.
How to handle a change in facts after receiving a Private Letter Ruling?
- If there's a material change in the facts after you've received a PLR but before or during the transaction, you should consider requesting a supplemental PLR from the IRS to confirm the original ruling still applies or to obtain a new ruling based on the changed facts.
How to find publicly available Private Letter Rulings for research purposes?
- Redacted PLRs are published by the IRS and can be accessed through the IRS FOIA Library on their website or through various commercial tax research services (e.g., Bloomberg Tax, Thomson Reuters Checkpoint).
 |
