Fullmetal Alchemist vs. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood: A Tale of Two Alchemists (and Why One Might Leave You Feeling Like You Missed a Limb)
Ah, Fullmetal Alchemist. A name that sends shivers down the spines of anime fans, conjuring images of spunky brothers, equivalent exchange, and enough angst to fuel a goth convention. But wait! There are two Fullmetal Alchemists? Brotherhood, non-Brotherhood, what's the deal? Relax, buckle up, and prepare for a crash course in alchemical confusion, with a healthy dose of humor (because let's face it, even alchemy needs a laugh track).
First things first: Both series tell the story of the Elric brothers, Edward and Alphonse, on a quest to get their bodies back after a transmutation mishap (think science experiment gone horribly wrong, but with more circles and chanting). But that's where the similarities end, and things get interesting.
Plotlines Diverge Like Ed's Automail Arm:
-
FMA (non-Brotherhood): This one takes some creative liberties, venturing off on its own path halfway through. Think of it as an alternate universe where Ed meets a homunculus named Dante (think Homunculus = living embodiment of a sin, but with way more fabulous fashion sense). The ending? Let's just say it involves portals to other worlds and Ed cosplaying as a Nazi soldier (don't worry, it's more confusing than offensive).
-
FMAB (Brotherhood): This anime sticks closer to the original manga, following the brothers on a more faithful journey. Expect more action, more characters, and an ending that actually makes sense (no Nazi cosplay, we promise). It's like the director's cut of the story, with all the good bits and none of the head-scratchers.
Characters: A Homunculus Family Reunion:
-
FMA: Meet Sloth, who turns out to be Ed and Al's mom (awkward!), and Wrath, who's their former teacher (double awkward!). The homunculi (remember, those sin-embodying guys?) have different origins and motivations here.
-
FMAB: All the homunculi are created by Father, the big baddie, and they're generally more fleshed out (pun intended, since some of them are literally made of flesh). Plus, no surprise mom reveals!
Overall Feel:
-
FMA: Starts dark and serious, but gets lighter and more episodic in the second half. Think of it as angsty teen with a rebellious streak.
-
FMAB: Maintains a more consistent tone, balancing action, humor, and emotional moments. It's like the angsty teen who's matured into a responsible young adult (but still with a cool metal arm).
So, which one should you watch?
Honestly, it depends on your mood and tolerance for confusion. FMAB is generally considered the better and more faithful adaptation. But if you're feeling adventurous and don't mind a mind-bend, FMA can be an interesting watch (just don't blame us if you end up needing therapy).
Remember, equivalent exchange applies to anime choices too. Choose wisely, my friend, and happy viewing!