"Which one should I choose: USAA or Allstate?"
This is a question many consumers, particularly those with a military affiliation, grapple with when seeking insurance. Both USAA and Allstate are powerhouses in the insurance industry, offering a wide array of products and services. However, their target markets, operational philosophies, and even their pricing structures can differ significantly. Understanding these nuances is key to making an informed decision that best suits your individual needs.
This lengthy guide will walk you through a detailed comparison of USAA and Allstate, examining everything from eligibility and coverage to customer satisfaction and financial strength. By the end, you'll have a clear picture of which insurer might be the perfect fit for you.
Step 1: Understanding Who They Are – Are You Even Eligible for USAA?
Before we dive deep into policy specifics and customer reviews, the absolute first step is to determine if USAA is even an option for you.
 |
| How Does Usaa Compare To Allstate |
USAA: Exclusivity and Service to the Military Community
USAA, or the United Services Automobile Association, is renowned for its unwavering dedication to the military community. This isn't just a marketing slogan; it's fundamental to their business model.
-
Who is eligible?
- Active Duty Military: Members of the U.S. Air Force, Army, Coast Guard, Marine Corps, Navy, and Space Force.
- Veterans: Those who have honorably separated or retired from the U.S. Armed Forces.
- Cadets and Midshipmen: Officer candidates in U.S. service academies, ROTC, and OCS/OTS.
- Eligible Family Members: This is where it gets a little broader. Spouses, widows, unremarried former spouses of USAA members, and children whose parents have or had USAA auto or property insurance are typically eligible. Grandchildren are generally not eligible directly unless their parent (the child of the USAA member) also establishes their own membership.
-
What does this mean for you? If you or a direct family member (as defined by USAA's strict criteria) has served, or is currently serving, in the U.S. military, then USAA is a strong contender. If not, then Allstate will be your primary focus.
Allstate: Insurance for Everyone
Allstate, on the other hand, is a publicly traded company that serves the general public. There are no specific eligibility requirements based on profession or affiliation.
- Who can get Allstate? Anyone seeking insurance services, from auto and home to life and business, can typically apply for an Allstate policy, provided they meet standard underwriting criteria (e.g., driving record, credit score, property location).
Step 2: Comparing Coverage Options: What Do They Offer?
Once eligibility is sorted, the next crucial step is to compare the types of coverage each insurer provides. Both offer a comprehensive suite of insurance products, but there can be subtle differences in their offerings and endorsements.
Tip: A slow, careful read can save re-reading later.
Auto Insurance: On the Road with USAA vs. Allstate
Both companies offer the standard array of auto insurance coverages:
- Liability Coverage: Bodily injury and property damage.
- Collision Coverage: Covers damage to your car from an accident.
- Comprehensive Coverage: Protects against non-collision incidents like theft, vandalism, and natural disasters.
- Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage: Protects you if you're hit by a driver with insufficient or no insurance.
- Personal Injury Protection (PIP) / Medical Payments (MedPay): Covers medical expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of fault.
Unique Offerings and Key Differences:
-
USAA's Auto Insurance Highlights:
- Car Replacement Assistance: If your vehicle is totaled, this coverage might pay out the actual cash value plus an additional percentage (e.g., 20%) of its value, which can be a significant benefit for newer cars.
- Storage Savings: A valuable benefit for deployed military members, allowing them to save money on their auto insurance while their vehicle is stored.
- Accident Forgiveness: May prevent your rates from increasing after your first at-fault accident.
- Discounts for Military-Specific Situations: Such as a discount for garaging your car on a military base.
-
Allstate's Auto Insurance Highlights:
- Drivewise Program: A telematics program that monitors driving behavior and offers discounts for safe driving habits. This can lead to substantial savings for careful drivers.
- Milewise: A pay-per-mile insurance option ideal for low-mileage drivers, where your premium is largely based on how much you drive.
- New Car Replacement: If your new car is totaled within its first few years, Allstate may replace it with a brand new one, not just its depreciated value.
- Deductible Rewards: You can earn money off your collision deductible for each year you drive without violations.
- Rideshare Insurance: Specific coverage for those who drive for services like Uber or Lyft.
Homeowners Insurance: Protecting Your Dwelling
Both USAA and Allstate provide standard homeowners insurance coverage, including:
- Dwelling Coverage: Protects the physical structure of your home.
- Personal Property Coverage: Covers your belongings (furniture, electronics, clothing).
- Liability Coverage: Protects you if someone is injured on your property.
- Additional Living Expenses (ALE): Covers costs if you need to live elsewhere while your home is being repaired after a covered loss.
Unique Offerings and Key Differences:
-
USAA's Homeowners Insurance Highlights:
- Earthquake and Flood Coverage: Often available as separate policies or endorsements, which can be crucial in certain geographical areas.
- Valuable Personal Property Coverage: Specific protection for high-value items like jewelry, art, and collectibles, often with higher limits than standard personal property coverage.
- Strong reputation for claims handling, especially in disaster situations.
-
Allstate's Homeowners Insurance Highlights:
- Identity Theft Restoration: Optional add-on coverage that provides assistance and financial support if you become a victim of identity theft.
- Water Backup Coverage: Important for protecting against damage from sewer backups or sump pump overflows.
- Claim-Free Discount: Savings for those who switch to Allstate without a recent home insurance claim.
- Multi-Policy Discounts: Allstate often offers significant savings when you bundle your home and auto policies.
Other Insurance Products:
Beyond auto and home, both companies offer a variety of other insurance products:
- USAA: Renters, Motorcycle, RV, Boat, Life, Umbrella, Health, Small Business, and Travel insurance.
- Allstate: Renters, Motorcycle, RV, Boat, Life, Umbrella, Business, and Event insurance.
Step 3: Discounts and Pricing: Getting the Best Value
Price is often a major factor in choosing an insurer. While individual quotes vary wildly based on personal factors (location, driving record, vehicle type, credit score, claims history, etc.), we can examine general pricing trends and available discounts.
USAA Pricing and Discounts:
USAA is often lauded for its competitive rates, particularly for its eligible members. Their direct-to-consumer model, without a vast network of physical agents, can contribute to these savings.
- Average Rates: While specific numbers fluctuate, many reports indicate USAA's auto insurance rates are often lower than the national average. For example, some analyses show USAA's average annual full coverage rate around $1,464, compared to a national average of $2,290.
- Key Discounts:
- Multi-Policy Discount: Bundling auto with home or renters insurance.
- Good Driver Discount: For maintaining a clean driving record.
- Safe Driver Discount: Based on driving habits (similar to telematics, but USAA's programs might differ).
- Vehicle Storage Discount: As mentioned, a big plus for deployed military personnel.
- New Vehicle Discount: For newer cars.
- Good Student Discount: For students maintaining good grades.
- Defensive Driving Course Discount: For completing approved courses.
- Loyalty Discounts: For long-term members.
Allstate Pricing and Discounts:
Allstate's rates can be more variable, and in some cases, might be higher than USAA, especially for those who don't qualify for significant discounts. However, their extensive discount programs can help bridge that gap.
QuickTip: Slow down when you hit numbers or data.
- Average Rates: Allstate's average full coverage auto insurance can be higher than the national average, with some reports putting it around $2,961 per year. However, these are averages, and individual rates vary significantly.
- Key Discounts: Allstate offers a plethora of discounts to help make their policies more affordable:
- Multi-Policy Discount: Significant savings when bundling home and auto.
- Safe Driving Discounts (Drivewise): As detailed above, can lead to substantial premium reductions based on driving habits.
- New Car Discount: For new vehicles.
- Anti-Lock Brake and Anti-Theft Device Discounts: For safety features.
- Good Student Discount: For eligible students.
- Defensive Driving Course Discount: For completing approved courses.
- Smart Student Discount: If you're under 25 and meet certain academic or driver education requirements.
- Easy Pay Plan Discount: For setting up automatic payments.
- Responsible Payer Discount: For consistent, on-time payments.
- Welcome & Loyalty Discount: For switching to Allstate and staying with them.
- Home Buyer Discount: For recent home purchases or newly constructed homes.
- Protective Device Discount: For homes with fire or theft protection systems.
Step 4: Customer Satisfaction and Claims Handling: The True Test
Beyond price and coverage, the experience you have with your insurer, particularly when you need to file a claim, is paramount.
USAA Customer Satisfaction:
USAA consistently ranks exceptionally high in various customer satisfaction surveys and ratings. They are known for their commitment to their members and often receive top marks for their claims handling process.
 |
- J.D. Power Ratings: Historically, USAA has often topped J.D. Power's customer satisfaction studies for auto and home insurance, though they are often excluded from public rankings due to their membership restrictions. When evaluated, customers give largely positive feedback.
- NAIC Complaint Index: USAA typically has fewer than the expected number of complaints relative to its size, indicating high customer satisfaction.
- Overall Reputation: Many members praise USAA for its easy-to-use platforms, responsive customer service, and efficient claims process, especially during times of crisis. However, some recent customer reviews on platforms like the BBB mention difficulties getting in touch with a person and an increase in rates.
Allstate Customer Satisfaction:
Allstate generally receives good ratings for customer satisfaction, though they may not consistently rank as high as USAA in certain categories. They are recognized for their user-friendly digital tools and commitment to a transparent claims process.
- J.D. Power Ratings: Allstate often receives average to above-average scores in J.D. Power's studies for overall customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction.
- NAIC Complaint Index: Allstate typically has a close to expected number of complaints relative to its size, which is generally considered a neutral to good performance.
- Overall Reputation: Allstate is praised for its comprehensive coverage options and various discount opportunities. They also offer a "Claim Satisfaction Guarantee" which allows a review from a senior claims adjuster if dissatisfied with an initial decision. Some online discussions, however, mention potential issues with claim denials and rate hikes after the first year.
Step 5: Financial Strength and Stability: How Secure Are They?
An insurance company's financial strength is vital, as it indicates their ability to pay out claims, especially during widespread catastrophic events.
USAA Financial Strength:
USAA consistently earns top-tier financial strength ratings from independent agencies, reflecting its exceptional ability to meet its financial obligations.
- A.M. Best: A++ (Superior) – the highest possible rating.
- Moody's Investors Service: Aaa (Exceptional) – the highest possible rating.
- Standard & Poor's (S&P): AA+ (Very Strong) – one of the highest ratings.
Allstate Financial Strength:
Allstate also boasts excellent financial strength ratings, demonstrating its robust financial health.
QuickTip: Don’t rush through examples.
- A.M. Best: A+ (Superior) – a very strong rating.
- Standard & Poor's (S&P): AA- (Very Strong) – a very strong rating.
- Moody's Investors Service: A1 (Good) – a strong rating.
Both companies are financially stable and reliable, so this factor is less likely to be a differentiator unless you are looking for the absolute highest possible ratings.
Step 6: The Verdict: Which One Is Right For YOU?
The choice between USAA and Allstate ultimately comes down to your personal circumstances and priorities.
-
Choose USAA if:
- You (or an eligible family member) have a military affiliation. This is the most critical factor.
- You prioritize exceptional customer service and claims handling. USAA consistently ranks at the top in this regard.
- You value competitive rates that often come with the added benefit of being a member-owned organization.
- You appreciate military-specific benefits like storage savings for vehicles.
- You're looking for a one-stop shop for insurance, banking, and investment products.
-
Choose Allstate if:
- You do not have a military affiliation that qualifies you for USAA membership.
- You are a safe driver and want to leverage telematics programs like Drivewise to potentially lower your premiums.
- You drive fewer miles and are interested in a pay-per-mile option like Milewise.
- You're looking for a wide array of discounts, and are willing to bundle policies to maximize savings.
- You prefer working with a local agent for a more personalized experience (Allstate has a large network of agents).
- You need specific add-on coverages like identity theft restoration or new car replacement.
10 Related FAQ Questions
Here are 10 common "How to" questions related to choosing an insurance provider, with quick answers:
How to: Determine my USAA eligibility?
Answer: Visit the USAA website or contact their customer service directly. They have clear guidelines on who qualifies for membership, primarily based on military service (active, veteran, cadet) or direct family relation (spouse, unremarried former spouse, child) to an eligible member.
How to: Get an insurance quote from USAA?
Answer: If eligible, you can get a quote online through their website or by calling their dedicated phone lines. You'll need personal information, vehicle details, and desired coverage levels.
How to: Get an insurance quote from Allstate?
Answer: You can get an Allstate quote online, through their mobile app, or by contacting a local Allstate agent. You'll provide similar information regarding your personal details, vehicles, and desired coverage.
Tip: Keep your attention on the main thread.
How to: Compare coverage options effectively?
Answer: Request detailed quotes from both companies, outlining the exact same coverage limits and deductibles for each policy type (auto, home, etc.). Pay attention to any unique endorsements or programs offered by each.
How to: Understand insurance discounts?
Answer: Ask each insurer for a comprehensive list of all available discounts and inquire which ones you qualify for. Make sure to factor these into your overall cost comparison.
How to: Assess customer service quality?
Answer: Look at independent third-party ratings from organizations like J.D. Power, review customer feedback on consumer review sites (like the BBB or various forums), and consider asking friends or family about their experiences.
How to: Check an insurance company's financial strength?
Answer: Refer to ratings from independent agencies such as A.M. Best, Standard & Poor's (S&P), and Moody's. These ratings indicate an insurer's ability to pay claims.
How to: Bundle policies for maximum savings?
Answer: Both USAA and Allstate offer multi-policy discounts. Inquire about bundling your auto and home/renters insurance, or other policies, to see the potential savings.
How to: Switch insurance providers smoothly?
Answer: Once you've chosen a new provider, make sure your new policy is active before canceling your old one to avoid any coverage gaps. Inform your old insurer of your cancellation date, and ensure you receive any prorated refunds.
How to: Re-evaluate my insurance needs periodically?
Answer: It's a good practice to review your insurance policies annually or whenever major life changes occur (e.g., buying a new car or home, getting married, having children). This ensures your coverage remains adequate and you're still getting the best value.
 |
This page may contain affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
💡 Breath fresh Air with this Air Purifier with washable filter.
